In a previous article on this site, there was a pretty intense conversation in the comments about “passionless” Starbucks partners. That inspired this article.
I should make it clear that I don’t think Starbucks is unique. The same conversations about how do you create employees can be had in almost any context. All of the skills that make a great Starbucks partner are the same skills that make a great employee in almost any career. And Starbucks suffers from some of the same challenges of any major retailer – some employees love what they do, while others couldn’t care less.
There are only a tiny number of careers where you don’t have to deliver great customer service, have good people skills, and create some magic. And well, let’s be totally honest: many careers require at least a minimal amount of faking it, and some amount of ass-kissing. (Sorry to be blunt.)
People are atrociously flawed. We are all full of shortcomings. (I could easily list a long list of flaws for myself! LOL). That moment in time when an employee encounters a customer is just a tiny snapshot in time. Neither one knows the context often fueling the interaction. One huge fallacy is that there is something mysterious about either partners or Starbucks customers. People are people. People can be baffled, confused, misunderstood in any setting. You’re doing a real disservice once you start pointing fingers on either side of the counter and thinking that the problem is customer or the problem is employees. We all make mistakes and have these moments where we don’t handle a situation with the finesse and skill required at that moment.
It isn’t the flaws that are the problem. It is how we deal with mistakes that matter. On the long list of human flaws is that many people are much too prideful. They don’t want to admit they’re wrong. This also causes escalating tensions. Once in a while, I’ll hear a retail employee say something like, “I’m never going to give in to customers,” and sometimes what that translates into is “I’m much too prideful to do the right thing in this context.” Actually, this pridefulness that says “I’m not going to budge” doesn’t work well for anyone.
A brand is not just a logo. It’s the sum of the interactions between customers and employees, and the emotions that flow from those experiences. It is almost always the challenge of the employee to figure out how to deliver the high-road result. The reason for that is that they are the ones who are expected to maintain the brand experience.
Starbucks positions itself as a premium brand. Like a Nordstrom, Sheraton Hotels, Whole Foods, or Williams Sonoma, Starbucks strives to be a premium brand.
It is true that when we pay a little more for something, we tend to expect a better experience. There’s no doubt that if you’re shopping at Ross Dress For Less, you might expect a different kind of experience than clothes shopping at Nordstrom. And, you’d expect a very different experience if staying at a Motel 6 versus a Sheraton Hotel. I think that many people perceive Starbucks as “expensive,” and it is true that the beverages are designed with a wide profit margin. Whether intuitively or not, when people feeling like they’re paying a little more for something, they expect that it will deliver a little more – a smile, and a great beverage or food item.
And as I cycle back to talking about Starbucks, there are some ways that Starbucks is unique. Starbucks provides some great tools to help partners deliver a great experience. In fact, if you were to adopt some of the ideals and strategies that I mention below, they’d help you in any career. They’re good life skills. Few employers do such a great job of spelling what works in delivering a great experience.
For Starbucks, the magic in delivering great experiences boils down to two things. The first is good hiring decisions. The second is providing the tools and skills to deliver upon the brand promise. Starbucks is good at finding great people, and finding ways to coach them in the right direction! Not everyone is a good fit. I think I heard somewhere that Starbucks now employees 200,000 people. You can’t hire that huge of a number and not have a few hits and misses.
I reiterate: a brand is not just a logo. It is all that happens between customers and employees. It’s those conversations about the brand that happen between friends much later, after the business transaction is long over, and the customer has walked out of the store.
There are a few strategies that Starbucks employs that really help to deliver great experiences consistently. And as I’ve mentioned – these are great life skills. Adopt these strategies, and they’ll help you in any career.
The Five Ways of Being – The Green Apron Behaviors.
Be Welcoming – Offer everyone a sense of belonging. It doesn’t hurt to greet customers immediately. I think being welcoming is an obvious good thing.
Be Genuine – Connect. Respond. Discover – Connect with the customer to figure out how to best deliver what he or she wants. Anticipate what he or she might want or like. It helps when you yourself deliver a genuine side – no need to put on any airs. I would say that partners can personalize the experience. I don’t think customers or partners like it if they feel like they have to deliver an identical script to each customer – that’s not really connecting or personalizing.
Be Involved – Connect with one another, with the company, and with the community. Starbucks offers lots of opportunities to get involved. It’s a great altruistic goal. Both customers and partners can log into the Starbucks Community website and look for volunteering projects to get involved with. I just now logged in and looked around a bit. As a totally random example of things you might fine, you’ll notice things like partners in Nashville, Tennessee looking for more volunteers to donate their time at a food bank.
Be Knowledgeable – Love what you do, and share it with others. It always helps to know your job well. I will say that one way Starbucks is unique is that they change more rapidly and more often than many brands. I can see how a partner might feel like they’ve got things down, and then policies and products change. Lots of jobs though require a person to flexible and keep on top of an ever-changing industry.
Be Considerate – Take care of yourself, each other, and the environment. This is self explanatory.
And how do you deal with those tense moments where a customer complains? “My drink isn’t perfect.” (What’s important to each customer will vary so much. Some customers will be more put off by over-filled trashcans than a less than perfect drink. Priorities are different for each customer. Some just want a fast drink.)
The LATTE method of delivering great customer service – again, this would be useful whether you worked at Quiznos, Starbucks, or whatever.
Listen to the customer, Acknowledge their complaint, Take action by solving the problem, Thank them, and then Explain why the problem occurred. (Or in the alternative, Escalate to someone above the level of the barista, if necessary – “escalate” isn’t part of the Starbucks training materials (as far as I know), but I thought it made sense here, so I threw it in.)
If someone is really following the LATTE method of delivering great experiences, he or she will be able to handle the overwhelming number of uncomfortable situations.
One thing that helps is to give people the benefit of the doubt. It helps to assume the best of intentions in others. It’s how everyone would hope to be treated, if the shoe was on the other foot. For customers who know the brand well, or partners who are there every day, the experience is not befuddling. But for others – even customers who go often enough to get a gold card (considering that 30 times a year is not a lot) the experience can be confusing. Beverages change. Food changes. Today I watched a woman totally confused at the register (it really looked like it could be her first visit ever to Starbucks) asked the register barista what the difference between an espresso macchiato and a caramel macchiato is. I recall another time recently talking a gold card holder customer who had no idea that you could use a reward for food. Starbucks changes often – both sides of the counter have to work to keep up!
The last thing is simply this: Empower employees to deliver something great. Once in a while I’ve heard partners say that they’ll get yelled at for ‘just saying yes’ or using the ‘right now recovery’ button. If you’re going to set yourself up as a premium brand experience, you have to give employees the ability to deliver on it, where needed. Hopefully Starbucks management is backing up employees when they do whatever is right to deliver a great experience. No employee should ever be admonished for doing the right thing!
You can be in any career, but so few really teach people how to deliver good customer/client experiences. I remember one time being on a frustrating phone call with a civil attorney, and losing my cool. After I got off the phone, I ran and told a good friend at work about my frustrations. And all he could say was (1) good thing that wasn’t a client and (2) nobody comes out of law school a kinder and gentler person than before they entered it. Ain’t that the truth. Law schools sure as heck don’t teach customer service. Lots of lawyers would benefit from adopting the Green Apron Behaviors! For further reading, there’s a great Forbes article about how doctors often don’t get enough people skills training, comparing Starbucks baristas to physicians.
I don’t expect every Starbucks experience to be a dream. And I know that they make plenty of mistakes. The difference is whether you learn from them, and corporate philosophy to guide and coach partners in the right direction – I think this one thing that Starbucks has that not all brands have.
And frankly, I am pretty convinced that there are lots of very passionate Starbucks partners out there working very hard to bring the brand experience to life. I hate to see the partners who are giving 110% not recognized because of one bad experience.
As you can see this article isn’t really just about Starbucks. You can take these lessons and apply them to just about any career.
(I think this has been a downer of an article. I’ll be sure to post something fun and uplifting for tomorrow.)
Related posts
18 Comments
Leave a Reply Cancel reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Sponsors
Recent Comments
- DEVIN on Compostable Straws Land in Seattle Starbucks Stores
- coffeebeanz on Why do you go to Starbucks less often? (If that’s true for you)
- Willi on You can now buy a Siren statue: $6,000
- Willi on A major revamp of your drink recipe: Testing syrup extracts and cane sugar
- Skip on Why do you go to Starbucks less often? (If that’s true for you)
I really enjoyed this article. There are many things that other corporations can learn from Starbucks. Even companies like Amazon, Costco, Whole Foods, Trader Joes, etc can teach other companies a lot. Reading Michelli’s “Leading the Starbucks Way” put this into perspective.
@Dylan – The 2 books about Starbucks written by Joseph Michelli are pretty amazing! I like that one too. I think they should just about be required reading. 😉
Thanks Melody–great post. Thanks for bringing to light the great work that many Starbucks partners do every day, developing an emotional intelligence that surpasses many professions. There are so many heroic and amazing things done every day that we don’t hear about.
@Melody – could not have said better myself 😉 .
It is hard to distill the customer employee employer relationship, but I boil it down to attitude. No matter where you are in the chain, just because one element in the chain has a bad attitude does not give you permission to have a bad attitude too. In fact you must work harder to affect a positive change in attitude.
I particularly like your comment about “many careers require at least a minimal amount of faking it, and some amount of ass-kissing. (Sorry to be blunt.)”
Another great article, Melody. It’s an interesting thing being in customer service – if you are genuine, 90% of the time that will take you very far (assuming, of course, that your “Genuine” means friendly, welcoming, etc. – not a genuine grump). However, that other 10% of the time, you do have to pretend and do what it takes to ensure a customer’s satisfaction, even if you may disagree with their version of events.
Just yesterday I was able to recover service from someone who adamantly wanted to talk to my boss – I was happy to give her that information, but took the time to listen to her complaint and genuinely apologize for her poor experience, and invite her to come back. At the end of the conversation, she was much calmer and felt satisfied knowing someone had taken the time to listen and genuinely care. And I was glad knowing I’d done what I could, in the moment, to represent myself, my partners, and our brand!
I think it was another one of your blog readers who posted “You never need permission to say yes to a customer” – I’d never heard it phrased quite that way before, but it really resonated with me and I’ve started sharing it with my partners.
Finally, you’re so right that proper hiring is HUGE and a foundational part of great customer experiences. If I have to explain why putting the needs of the customer first may sometimes mean putting your pride (and need to be “right”) on hold, chances are that lesson won’t stick. I’m always looking to hire partners who see that each customer is a person – not just a part of a faceless mob!
Again, great article – love how you relate it to career successes, as well! It’s bigger than Starbucks 🙂
@DadCooks – Thanks. I felt like adding in a little more and expanding that. Try “faking it until you make it.” But at 1700 words, it’s already too long of a blog post – yet oddly, I think I could have written another 1700 words. I didn’t really fully develop all the themes I wanted to.
@Lauren – Starbucks needs to clone you! Having met you in real life, I know you’re awesome. I’m sure you put the customer at ease. Years and years ago I used to work for a dentist who would say things like, “the dentists who get sued for malpractice are the ones who don’t really talk to and listen to their clients…” Real listening is such a skill. I hope we can catch up next time I am in Southern California!
Love this article. I like to think I am one of the passionate ones…but that is in most areas for me:) and I agree with the the hiring point you made, they hire some good people.
@Anna – Thank you for being so passionate! I love all your Instagram pics!
Very well said: insightful and eloquent.
I’ve just started re-reading Onward, yet again, and I am reminded of what Howard wrote (pp. 4-5):
“I love Starbucks because everything we’ve tried to do is steeped in humanity. Respect and dignity. Passion and laughter. Compassion, community, and responsibility. Authenticity. These are Starbucks’ touchstones, the source of our pride.”
When we as partners get it right for our customers it’s magical. Thank you for this post.
Melody first I have to say I do not think this is a downer post, but rather in lots of ways a positive post. Your comments should be read over and over again. I agree with Dad Cooks that attitude has so much to do with customer service. Again, just so there is no confusion- I do know there are partners with passion but I also know that from store to store the training that goes on and the passion differs so as we all know partners are different. Of course, so are customers! This post should be put in the back room of stores. I also like the quote that Organic Fair Trade Dave posted from Howard.
@Purple1 – Well part of what I wanted to do was spotlight that Starbucks has all the right strategies in place to make something dynamic happen everywhere. It’s up to district managers and store managers to bring that to life. Leadership makes all the difference. Sometimes, it feels like every partner in the world is reading this blog – just because between this blog & the FB side it all stays busy, and then I have this reality moment when I realize how few people this blog really reaches. What I hope is that this kind of post will reach a lot of people, and at a minimum give them pause for thought about the dynamics of their business.
In the refill policy thread, there was this post about a customer getting into a “shouting match” with a barista. Somethings gone wrong if that’s happening. Just say yes. And, there should be (there in fact are) good strategies in place to manage most of what will happen inside the stores.
I thoroughly enjoyed this blog post–it wasn’t a downer at all. On the contrary, it’s filled with nuggets of wisdom that can be, as you mentioned, applied to all careers. Good, genuine, effective customer service cannot be underestimated. It’s priceless, not only for the brand/company, but for the individual…self-development wise. Knowing how to communicate well, listen, solve problems to the best of your ability, and anticipate the needs of customers/clients/vendors (well people in general, honestly) are skills that will take you far in your professional life and just in your relationships with people overall. Not too long ago I had a conversation with my mother about how I feel many companies emphasize and celebrate the hard skills people possess, but that same enthusiasm isn’t there for those who possess keen soft skills (people skills) and many times avenues to develop and foster those skills within organizations are sometimes nonexistent.
Thanks for sharing your thoughts on the topic. It was a very good read and I’ll check out the Forbes article you referenced, too.
I came to the Starbucks party late, for years I drank what I bought at Costco in those huge bulk bags and that was okay…but got old fast! I was in the market for something different, but stayed away from Starbucks because of the rumored, “it tastes burnt.” Reluctantly, I tried it and it was LOVE!
One of the things I *love* about Starbucks is their commitment to providing consistent customer service with high standards of excellence no matter which store you go to. I was so inspired and loved it so much I bought a used Starbucks training manual! Reading it I kept saying, “Wow!” I was both touched and genuinely impressed.
I *love* the quote @Organic Fair Trade Dave shared, focusing on humanity is always a win-win.
Starbucks inspires greatness which is uncommon in this ‘me’ over-marketed society. Not everyone wants to be great…
I am a grateful, probably lifelong, Starbucks customer. Thank you for your post. 🙂
I really do enjoy this article, especially the beginning (noteably “One thing that helps is to give people the benefit of the doubt. It helps to assume the best of intentions in others. It’s how everyone would hope to be treated, if the shoe was on the other foot.”), because it’s very true in retail and something customers don’t think about often imo: that each interaction is a very small one. I think sometimes customers have high standards to the point where they forget to have a little forgiveness for someone working an 8 hour shift and is probably trying to keep it together. That said, of course it’s important for employees to do their best to be cheerful as well, and I think both customers and employees can benefit from a little forgiveness. For every tired barista just starting a shift, there is a tired customer just ending one. Also when you’re having a terrible day, sometimes all it takes is one sweet, kind customer to make you feel human again. A lovely article.
@Noon – So much truth in what you wrote! I think about that all the time – when I drop by Starbucks at 8:00 am or 8:30 am on my way into work, I realize that some of those partners have been there already for hours! You’re right – definitely need to forgive tired baristas. Both customers and partners can benefit from a little forgiveness. Thank you for finding my blog and leaving a comment! (Hope you’ll subscribe – there’s a spot in the right side column to enter an email address.)
I subscribed using bloglovin, if you don’t mind. 🙂 I check that more often than my email, haha.
@Noon – Sounds very good! Thank you! I sometimes forget that I put up that bloglovin’ widget – but it’s there for a reason – there is a sizeable group of people who use Bloglovin’!