Starbucks Colombia Coffee and Colombia Via: Taste and Compare

Today (2-26-2012) I dropped by the Starbucks at Fourth and Union in downtown Seattle and hoped to be able to do a quick coffee tasting.  This was spontaneous.  I didn’t know who would be working and I didn’t know if they’d be too busy.

A little over one week ago, a partner in Canada (who had just been on a vacation to Mexico) mailed me a bag of Starbucks Colombia whole bean coffee.  I drooled when I got it.  Colombia is still a core coffee in a number of the international Starbucks markets.  Since I had never had the opportunity to taste and compare Colombia Via side by side with Colombia whole bean core coffee, I thought that might work as a quick and fun coffee tasting.

Three partners were there working on this Sunday morning Starbucks visit:  Helen, Aaron, and Jenny were all very interested in trying a quick coffee tasting.  It was a Sunday morning, and luckily, I seemed to time this with a slower moment in the store.  Aaron told me that he wants to start his coffee master training, and that he is really interested in getting more coffee tasting experience.  He made a French press of the Colombia and prepared everything.

I have to say we loved the Colombia whole bean coffee.  Aaron and I were totally impressed with the beautiful nutty flavor, and the smooth texture, and light cocoa notes too.  This is a near perfect cup of coffee.  Aaron commented that he liked it just slightly better than the Guatamela Antigua which had been a favorite core coffee of his.

The Colombia Via Ready Brew was also quite good, and held its own quite well.  I could detect some nuttiness to it, though it lacked the beautiful aroma found in the whole bean version.  Suddenly I did appreciate the Colombia Via more than I had before, and bought a pack of it to take home.  Although I like darker coffees, I really do enjoy a nice ‘medium’ roast too, and the Colombia is definitely that.

Aaron and I chatted about tastings a bit, and I decided that I would do a roundup of numerous previous coffee tasting articles on this blog to make them a little easier to find.  Here you go:

  • The Roast You Love the Most media event – (Food pairing) This was a coffee tasting that I went to at Olive Way Starbucks, and it was produced by Olive Way and the Starbucks PR department.  I was there with a number of other local bloggers.  This was a superbly well thought out coffee tasting of Veranda, Pike Place Roast, and Italian.  Anton at Olive Way is really good at putting on highly professional coffee events!
  • Ethiopia Hararr, Aged Sumatra, and more – (Food pairing) This was one of the regularly scheduled Olive Way coffee tasting events.  This again was an extremely professional, well thought out coffee tasting.  The Hararr was paired with the raisins from the Perfect Oatmeal, and that turned out to be a superb choice.  I hope you’ll read this one too!
  • The “butter” coffee tasting: Anniversary Blend - (Food pairing) This was a unique opportunity to try Anniversary Blend with some butter.  It really demonstrates some unusual things you can do to learn about, and try coffee. Mikey (also known as “Mr. Opportunity” – Just look at the window cling) put on a world-class tasting.
  • Sumatra Tapanuli and Rwanda Gakenke - (Taste and Compare – No food) At this Olive Way Starbucks event, coffee masters from the corporate headquarters hosted a special coffee tasting of new Reserve coffee offerings.  (Actually, all the food at this event was provided after we tried the coffees, as to not interfere with the comparison of the coffees.)
  • A barista earns her black apron – Christmas Blend, Pike Place Roast, and two Reserve coffees – (Food pairing) This was a coffee tasting event at the 6th and Union Starbucks (in downtown Seattle) produced by a barista earning her black apron.  It was a really fun event featuring four coffees, and especially great to see a partner given her black apron!
  • Casi Cielo coffee tasting at Olive Way – (Food pairing) This was one of the regularly scheduled Olive Way coffee tasting events.  Absolutely wonderful food pairings with Casi Cielo.  This store really has a knack for professional coffee events.
  • Bali Blend and core Starbucks Sumatra coffee – (Taste and compare) This was another one of my spontaneous moments where I dropped by my neighborhood Starbucks (7th and Pike), and wondered if the partners wanted to try one of the rare international coffees – Bali Blend.  This was a very classic, “taste and compare” style event, and we compared Bali Blend with the core Sumatra coffee at Starbucks.  Really a fantastic fun quick tasting.
  • Coffee tasting: Cupping Mexico blend – (Cupping) Mexico Blend is one of the international Starbucks coffee, and at this event we did a traditional “cupping” which is the coffee tasting method used by roasters to check for coffee quality.  It’s actually difficult to find a cupping at a Starbucks because most stores are not set up to do them.  Although this is a very old blog article, I thought I’d shine a spotlight on it too.
  • Galapogas Island Roasting event – This was not a coffee tasting really, but I wanted to mention this too.  There are regular roasting events at the Starbucks headquarters, and this was one of the very few times that I had the chance to go to one.  It was just a heck of a lot of fun, and something that I still look back very fondly on, and thankful that I had this opportunity.
  • Three Region Blend and plums – (Food pairing)  I asked two coffee masters at the First and Pike Starbucks to help me out in figuring out a way to feature Three Region Blend in a coffee tasting.  This is a really old blog post, and those partners aren’t even at that store anymore (I think they’re both still partners, just at different stores) but what they came up with was an incredibly superb selection of foods that highlight the best flavors of Three Region Blend.  Those two partners (Heidi and Jeremy) are true lovers of the bean, and have a natural knack for coffee tastings.
  • Sumatra Lake Toba – (Cupping) – A quick cupping event at 15th Avenue Coffee and Tea Starbucks featuring Sumatra Lake Toba coffee.
  • Organic Blue Java and a donut – (Food pairing) – This was an incredibly fast coffee tasting of Blue Java with a donut.  I just dropped by the First and Pike Starbucks, and caught up with Emily who radiates tons of passion for Starbucks.  She’s still a partner, just a different store now.  This is a really old blog post, but it shows how you can do a coffee tasting on the fly!
  • Breakfast Blend Via compared with Breakfast Blend whole bean – (Cupping) – I dropped by 15th Avenue Coffee and Tea Starbucks, which in the past has had regularly scheduled coffee events.  I suggested the idea of comparing a Via with its whole bean counterpart, and Amanda (who is an incredibly knowledgeable barista, and since then has been promoted in the headquarters) ran with the idea, and she set up this cupping.

There are more coffee tastings on this blog, but I think I’ll stop right there.  By the way, I mentally categorize coffee events into three categories: Cuppings, Food Pairings, and Taste and Compare.  This is NOT an official Starbucks categorization, but it seems to work for me to describe the most common ways to learn about coffee.  And, I am of the opinion that to learn the most about coffee, one should experience all three of these.

I am having some computer problems at the moment, and so I’m just using whatever computer I can right now.  I took these photos (from today’s Colombia tasting) on my phone on a low resolution setting so that I wouldn’t have to use a photo editor to re-size them.  Sorry that they’re not great quality.

Thank you again Aaron and everyone at the Fourth and Union Starbucks for a great quick tasting!

~Melody

(Edit:  After I wrote this article, I realized that some U.S. grocery stores sell Starbucks Colombia coffee!  That is a great find in the grocery store!)

Post to Twitter

37 Comments

  1. becca
    Feb 26, 2012 @ 14:41:55

    Hi Mel,

    I default to the Colombia VIA because the French is way to dark and the Italian is too dark for me for everyday. Thank you for the coffee tasting ideas

    @sssuperbecca

    Reply

  2. Leslee
    Feb 26, 2012 @ 14:47:09

    Hi Mel!!! Speaking of tasting… I received an email from Starbucks this week offering a free cute little tasting cup if I placed an order from a selct group of coffees. Much to my dismay, the Kcups were not offered! Dang it… I already have one tasting cup and they work nicely for shot glasses as well Another fav are the Via’s as they pack nicely for travel and lunchpails/desk drawers; those were not one of the selcet either… Booo!

    I will keep watch and maybe another special will pop up soon!

    Reply

  3. Michelle
    Feb 26, 2012 @ 14:52:08

    When I saw the photo of the Columbia whole bean before I read the article I said “What is that!” (yes, out loud) I haven’t tasted Columbia coffee but I have to be honest and say that I do not care for the Columbia VIA. I find it has a very strange smell and an odd aftertaste. I much prefer the Italian VIA to the Columbia.

    I’ll be honest and admit that when the French Roast VIA came out I was on vacation and so I missed the required pre-launch tasting, and somehow I’ve managed to get by without ever tasting it. Since all the French Presses in my store are broken (yes…all!) I think I will have my partners go through the VIA spectrum this week until our new ones arrive in our order Thursday.

    Reply

  4. Bo
    Feb 26, 2012 @ 14:53:57

    Wow, extensive and informative! I love Starbucks coffee but never really had to time to try most of their brews. I’m so glad to have read this — I’m pretty sure you just saved me load of hours researching it on my own. Thanks, Mel!

    @bosulie

    Reply

  5. denise r
    Feb 26, 2012 @ 15:02:23

    interesting post. However, for me, Colombia would not be a choice. I don’t care the Col. VIA at all….and yes, I could tell the difference back when it was all those taste tests of Colombia vs Italain. I just need my BOLD. (oh, I mean “dark” :)

    Reply

  6. Darkkatpouncing
    Feb 26, 2012 @ 15:34:55

    I think of all the coffee tasting options I like comparing coffee flavors the
    best – without food. I’ve tried with and without food and I guess I get too
    distracted by the food. So far of the starbucks brands I love Guatemala. blend
    the best though I still haven’t tried the Reserve Guatemala blend. From your description
    I feel I need to try the Columbia – I don’t think I’ve tried that one yet.
    My next bag of coffee for the office will be Columbia. I’m thinking I may have
    a new favorite ;)

    Reply

  7. Melody
    Feb 26, 2012 @ 15:37:56

    @darkkatpouncing – This Colombia coffee is only an international Starbucks offering – Which is a disappointment to me. The Reserve Guatemala Antigua Santa Catalina is wonderfully smooth and nice and is a superb medium option.

    Reply

  8. Hayley
    Feb 26, 2012 @ 15:38:21

    I didn’t realize that Columbia wasn’t a US whole bean…I feel unobservant. I guess I assumed it was the house blend. Wow. Thanks for this post!! I still have to say I do sort of like the simplicity and clean design of the bags!

    Reply

  9. elly
    Feb 26, 2012 @ 15:44:02

    you know, i would love to do some side by side comparisons of my own like this!

    i wonder if we could talk olive way or 15th insto some larger scale demos like this of the via/kcups/whole bean offerings that match up…

    Reply

  10. eric
    Feb 26, 2012 @ 15:48:58

    The only two I’ve compared are Christmas Blend and Christmas Blend VIA, but never to this level of detail. Mainly, I’ve bought the VIA to stretch my Christmas Blend into the spring — I prefer the whole bean but still enjoy the VIA. Thanks for the comparison!

    Reply

  11. Melody
    Feb 26, 2012 @ 15:51:33

    @eric – I guess we can do this again soon when Tribute Blend comes around. ;) By the way, do you follow me on twitter?
    @Elly – Maybe Olive Way would want to experiment with Via in their tastings, and I even kind of like that idea, but they do such incredibly superb tastings now, not sure I want to change a thing!

    Reply

  12. Dustin
    Feb 26, 2012 @ 16:59:03

    It’s interesting that you wrote about a tasting comparison of the Colombia next to the VIA.
    I led a coffee seminar over the summer, offering comparisons between all of our VIA and the whole bean counterpart. It was AMAZING.

    Some of the participants ended up choosing the VIA over the whole bean!

    Reply

  13. Melody
    Feb 26, 2012 @ 17:07:00

    @Dustin – Now that would be an interesting taste comparison. With House and BB as Via, that could be a long tasting but those are hard to find! Supposedly they’re in grocery stores but many stores around here just don’t have them. Very difficult to hunt down. By the way, does your market have decaf Verona Via Ready Brew? I’m confused by the pamphlets in stores that say, “Starbucks Roast Spectrum” and list decaf Verona as a Via option.

    Reply

  14. adel
    Feb 26, 2012 @ 20:02:55

    Did Starbucks name the coffee after the name of the building or did they name the building after the name of the coffee?

    Reply

  15. Melody
    Feb 26, 2012 @ 20:10:58

    @Adel – Not sure I follow. Colombia coffee comes from the country in Latin America – Colombia, It is spelled with two Os and no U.
    In Seattle, we do have the “Columbia Tower” which has the “U” and the name of the building has nothing to do with this coffee. In any case, the Columbia Tower has had a couple of different names too – I think it was once the Bank of America Tower. It used to be that most Starbucks coffees were named after a coffee growin region – And if you look at the Reserve coffees, those all have the name of the region where the coffee was grown in the name. Does that help?

    Reply

  16. Ernest
    Feb 27, 2012 @ 01:42:37

    An interesting post. You see, I also had my first taste of whole bean colombia coffee and I love it for the same reasons you mentioned here.

    Reply

  17. purple1
    Feb 27, 2012 @ 05:04:46

    Terrific post Melody. Love the fact that the partners were so willing to do the tastings and spend time with you. Liked reading about the comparison of the via vs. whole bean. I can pretty much tell you partners around here would not be as accomodating.

    Reply

  18. Diele
    Feb 27, 2012 @ 05:22:58

    Seems like ages since I have had Columbia. I have always wondered why it was discontinued. It sold well in the stores I was at. Perhaps there were just too many medium whole bean coffees that they wanted to trim it down to prevent waste. My dad adores the Columbia Via, so I wish we had the whole bean to surprise him with.

    Reply

  19. Becky E
    Feb 27, 2012 @ 08:07:18

    Great post, Melody. I love Christmas Blend Via but haven’t tried many of the others. Once my stash of CB Via runs out I was wondering which other Via would be a good stand in until the next holiday season?

    Reply

  20. Melody
    Feb 27, 2012 @ 08:18:36

    @becky Im on my phone, sorry sloppy. Stock up on Tribute Blend Via, It is coming soon. should be fantastic and had some aged sumatra beans which is a key part of Christmas Blend

    Reply

  21. Melody
    Feb 27, 2012 @ 08:18:36

    @becky Im on my phone, sorry sloppy. Stock up on Tribute Blend Via, It is coming soon. should be fantastic and had some aged sumatra beans which is a key part of Christmas Blend

    Reply

  22. Jonathan Smith ( Starbucks_RCM )
    Feb 27, 2012 @ 12:03:32

    Considering the Colombia is a medium roast, I think the roasters have done a fantastic job in creating what I see as a delicate roast in order to bring out such nutty flavours. They timed it just right.
    I supported the launch of VIA Ready Brew in the UK and Ireland market almost 3 years ago when it launched, and did several taste challenges with the PR team Edelman, as well as local journalists in London, and hand on heart, every single one of them couldn’t taste the difference between our fresh brewed Colombia and the Colombia VIA. We must remember however the Colombia brewed in French Press will accentuate the nutty flavours, and give a much richer aroma to that of the VIA, which is after all a high quality 100% Arabica Coffee, micro-ground so fine it’s soluble, and if I drink it compared to high street instant coffee, it wins for flavour and quality hands-down, and that’s my personal opinion of course :)

    Once I had so many sachets of the VIA Colombia after a media event in London, that on the train home back from London, on a virgin train service, I asked the cabin manager if I could do a coffee tasting, and I thought she’s bound to say no – but she didn’t. She actually agreed, and let me sample the coffee ( using their hot water on board ) and I did a coffee tasting with over 80 passengers. That was a day to remember for me I tell you !!

    I’m now eagerly awaiting the arrival of our new Blonde Roast which is sure to be a huge success to all those coffee drinkers who prefer a lighter coffee with some tangy and bright notes.

    Mel, thank you for all you do, for your honesty, transparency and genuine loyalty.

    Reply

  23. calwatch
    Feb 28, 2012 @ 00:31:08

    There needs to be tastings outside of Seattle and the other urban areas and out in the suburbs. More people should be exposed to the rest of the Starbucks menu.

    Reply

  24. Becky E
    Feb 28, 2012 @ 07:29:40

    Thanks for the suggestion, Melody. I look forward to trying the Tribute Via. Having the stores do tastings between Via and their whole bean counterpart is a great idea.

    Reply

  25. Diele
    Feb 28, 2012 @ 07:33:18

    I do tastings in Arizona. (: My new manager plans to certify me as a coffee master soon. I need to reread the materials and brush up for certification. Very excited to share my passion and knowledge at a new store.

    I wish the online store offered international offerings!

    Reply

  26. Nathan
    Feb 28, 2012 @ 14:00:04

    Although I’m more of a bold drinker, I love this coffee for the same reasons you’ve said. One thing I’ve been wondering though, does anyone know if this is the same coffee as the Colombia Narino Supremo from way back? Did they just change the name, or the coffee too? To me it tastes the same. If anyone knows for sure that’d be great.

    Reply

  27. Hayley
    Feb 28, 2012 @ 19:16:25

    @nathan I can’t say 100% but I am over 90% sure they are not the same, but the are both considered mediums and have similar notes. ;)

    @diele we need more of you here in AZ!

    Reply

  28. Melody
    Feb 28, 2012 @ 19:22:21

    @Hayley and @Nathan – In some twitter conversation, I think Jonathan (starbucks_rcm) mentioned to me that the two colombia coffees are the same. Hopefully he’ll come back here to the blog – He is a coffee expert!

    Reply

  29. Nicole Schuman
    Feb 29, 2012 @ 08:37:47

    Starbucks is really the best! They have varieties of coffees and it really taste heavenly! Thank you for sharing this! :)

    Reply

  30. Jared
    Mar 01, 2012 @ 19:02:30

    My wife and I saw Columbia whole bean coffee at the supermarket tonight. Given that its not sold at Starbucks stores here in the US, I was really surprised to see it at the supermarket.

    Reply

  31. Jonathan smith
    Mar 01, 2012 @ 21:59:26

    Not sure if Nathan saw my blog post on feb 27th but hopefully that answers his questions around the Colombia narino supremo uncertainty. :)

    Reply

  32. Becky E
    Mar 04, 2012 @ 05:50:02

    I’m glad you posted your find at the supermarket, Jared. I found the Colombia whole bean coffee here in Indiana at a Kroger grocery store a couple of days ago. Very same bag that Melody has pictured and that’s what caught my eye. It’s in whole bean form at this grocery and in ground form (same bag) across the street at Walmart.

    Reply

  33. Melody
    Mar 04, 2012 @ 08:19:06

    @Jared and @BeckyE – That’s amazing that this coffee is in grocery stores. I’ve totally missed that. Thank you for telling me! It’s such a shame that it is pre-ground!!! Ugh! In any case, I do a lot of my shopping at Whole Foods which doesn’t have Starbucks coffees or Via, but now I am going to be on the look out for this coffee.

    Reply

  34. Laura
    May 25, 2012 @ 10:27:35

    Melody, I do not know if you have found any Colombia closer to home, but I saw some yesterday in Bellevue, WA. The Target in the Factoria shopping center had bagged, pre-ground Colombia in a Starbucks display. Maybe all Targets in the area carry this?

    Reply

  35. Melody
    May 25, 2012 @ 10:40:45

    @Laura – Thanks for the info. I wish they had the Colombia in whole bean. I do most of my grocery shopping at the Whole Foods nearest to home (the one on Westlake) and WF doesn’t carry any Starbucks coffee! I’ve always found that a bit disappointing. I’ll keep looking. I might have to make a trip to Factoria. I’ve been meaning to get to the Loehmann’s Plaza Starbucks in Factoria.

    Reply

  36. Dave
    Mar 09, 2014 @ 10:04:26

    I’ve been buying Starbucks Columbia Medium whole bean at Publix grocery stores in Florida for many years. Last week I went to stock up on a few bags and they only had the pre-ground (ugh) Columbia on the shelf and no section for the whole bean. What’s going on? Has it been discontinued?
    I’m hooked on Columbia whole bean and need my coffee fix every morning. I’ve tried a few other flavors, but nothing compares to the taste of Columbia whole bean freshly ground coffee to start my day.
    Help!

    Reply

  37. Heidi
    Jun 03, 2014 @ 17:38:49

    Dave – we are having the same problem in the Chicago area. We can only find ground. Did you find anything out?

    Help here too!

    Reply

Leave a Reply